Projected impacts of Medicaid work requirements: An overview of current state proposals

As of January 2019, 14 states have submitted proposals to the federal government requesting permission to establish work requirements in their Medicaid programs. To date, the U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) has approved Medicaid work requirements for seven states, and two states (Arkansas and Indiana) have begun implementing these requirements for Medicaid beneficiaries.

In June 2018, Michigan enacted work requirements for many enrollees in the Healthy Michigan Plan (HMP), Michigan’s expanded Medicaid program for low-income adults.

Beginning in January 2020, HMP enrollees under age 63 will be required to report 80 hours of work per month or obtain an exemption (see CHRT’s previous fact sheet, Proposed Medicaid Work Requirements in Michigan).

The Michigan House Fiscal Agency initially estimated that approximately 80 percent of enrollees would be subject to the requirements, while 20 percent would qualify for an exemption.  More recently, an independent analysis by Manatt Health projected that 39 percent of HMP enrollees would be automatically exempt (based on age, pregnancy, medically frail, or incarceration status; or because they are already meeting SNAP/TANF work requirements), while 61 percent would be required to report work hours or obtain an exemption. This analysis estimated that 9 to 27 percent of all HMP enrollees could lose coverage over a one-year period.

Read Projected Impacts of Medicaid Work Requirements in Michigan.


Proposed work requirements for Medicaid in Michigan: April 20, 2018

At the start of 2018, the U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services announced a major shift in federal policy that would allow states to request permission to establish, and test the impact of, work and community engagement requirements for able-bodied adults receiving Medicaid health insurance coverage. In the last three months, work requirement proposals have been approved in three states; formal applications have been submitted by seven more; and a number of others are preparing proposals.

Read Full Brief Here

In early March, Michigan state senators took the first step toward preparing a work requirement proposal of their own by introducing Senate Bill 897. The bill passed the Michigan State Senate on April 19. In this fact sheet, we compare the characteristics and projected impact of Michigan’s Medicaid work requirement proposal against the characteristics and projected impact of approved work requirement proposals in Kentucky, Indiana, and Arkansas.

Health Insurance Marketplace in Michigan 2018: Rate Analysis


In 2017, the federal government took several regulatory and administrative actions that affect the health insurance marketplaces created under the Affordable Care Act (ACA). At the same time that Congress considered legislative proposals to repeal and replace the ACA, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) promulgated new regulations that changed annual open enrollment dates and announced the end of cost-sharing reduction payments to insurers. These developments, in addition to several other factors, have impacted Marketplace carrier participation and plan pricing in Michigan.

Key Findings

  • Michigan continues to have a robust Marketplace. Eight insurers are participating in Michigan’s health insurance marketplace in 2018, a decrease of two insurers from 2017.
  • Michigan consumers can select from a variety of Marketplace plans. There are 12 to 52 plans offered in each of Michigan’s 83 counties.
  • Across all counties, the average premium increase for the lowest cost and second-lowest cost silver plans is 33 percent and 34 percent, respectively. Premiums for the lowest cost bronze plan increased by 16 percent, and premiums for the lowest cost gold plan increased by 6 percent.
  • Premium tax credits are linked to the cost of the local second-lowest cost silver plan. All else equal, individuals who are eligible for premium tax credits could receive a larger tax credit in 2018 due to premium increases for the second-lowest cost silver plan. In 23 counties, larger tax credit amounts will eliminate the cost difference between renewing the 2017 lowest cost silver plan and actively enrolling in the 2018 lowest cost silver plan.
  • The federal government reduced the open enrollment period to 45 days, from 92 days in 2017.
  • Federal financial support for Michigan Navigators to help with open enrollment has been reduced by 72 percent, from $2,228,692 in 2017 to $627,958 in 2018.

For more, read Rate Analysis: 2018 Health Insurance Marketplace.